Chapter 2

Tufted Titmouse - Baeolophus bicolor
Just before the January thaw came along in late December, I was bringing in an armload of firewood. Through the crisp winter air I heard clear whistled notes: peeer ... peeer ... peeer. Though the wind was cold, I had to pause my usually brisk pace to be sure I had heard correctly: peeer ... peeer ... peeer. A Tufted Titmouse was singing. Was he a weather prognosticator who knew a warm front was on the way? And did that prompt him to get an early start in attracting a mate? Or was he just singing because the sun had made a brief appearance? - a cause for celebration during a weather-bleak week.

Later, I heard those clear whistled notes again, the song penetrating the insulated kitchen windows. Sometimes peeer  sometimes pee-ter - the latter contributing the folk name, “Peter-bird.”

Rather common, at least in the valleys, the Tufted Titmouse is a newcomer to Vermont - a flatlander from the south. Edward Forbush, the Massachusetts’ ornithologists, knew so little about this bird that he had to draw on the accounts of others for his description. The titmouse was a rarity in New England when he did his major work in the first half of the twentieth century. He listed its range as extending only to New Jersey and southern Pennsylvania.

The first breeding record for the titmouse in Vermont was in 1975 in Dorset. During the first “Vermont Breeding Bird Atlas (1976-1981),” there were only seven confirmed breeding records of the Tufted Titmouse (one was in Brattleboro). There was one probable breeding record, and five possible breeding records. The second “Vermont Breeding Bird Atlas (2003-2007)” recorded confirmations in survey blocks throughout the state. There is now no surprise at the presence of the Tufted Titmouse.

The Tufted Titmouse is a cavity nester, often taking over the old hole of the Downy Woodpecker. Primarily a forest bird, once the breeding season is complete it becomes a foraging opportunist. Audubon wrote that “it approaches the plantations, and even resorts to the granaries for corn.” Today, it uses the opportunities provided by bird feeders.

Audubon’s description of the titmouse’s feeding technique is worth quoting: “It moves along the branches, searches in the chinks, flies to the end of twigs and hangs to them by its feet, whilst the bill is engaged in detaching a beech or hazel nut, an acorn or a chinquapin, upon all of which it feeds, removing them to a large branch, where, having secured them in a crevice, it holds them with both feet, and breaks the shell by repeated blows of its bills. They are to be seen thus employed for many minutes at a time.”

I watch the titmouse do almost exactly what Audubon described, except that the “nut” which it carries to a tree to pound open with its beak is a sunflower seed. During its passage through the backyard, it goes back and forth from the feeder to a tree branch where it pries out the nutritious meat.

The strange name, “titmouse,” seems to derive from two Middle English words both of which have antecedents in earlier Germanic languages. “Tit” is a general term for anything small, while “mouse” derives from “mose” and means something like, “small bird.” So “titmouse” means (redundantly) a “small small-bird.” A few fussy language pedants insist that the plural of “titmouse” should be “titmouses,” but they are fighting a lost battle. “Titmice” is the accepted plural. Oh well, says one source, the bird has a mouse-like movement, so we should probably go along with more than one being “mice.”

Tufted Titmouse in winter
Sometimes when I consult Audubon’s Birds of America, I have difficulty finding the bird I want to read about because his names are often different than the current common names. However, I did not have trouble figuring out that our Tufted Titmouse is Audubon’s Crested Titmouse. But his account of the Crested Titmouse was then followed by accounts of the Black-cap Titmouse, Carolina Titmouse, Hudson’s Bay Titmouse, and several more titmice (titmouses!).

The latter accounts all described chickadees, respectively the Black-capped, Carolina, and Boreal Chickadees. Audubon was using the English term applied to members of the genus, Parus, which in his time included many closely related and similar appearing species, all of which bore the name “titmouse.” The North American titmice and chickadees, and the European titmice, still belong to the same family, Paridae, but DNA studies have resulted in separating them into six distinct genera. In North America, there are two genera, one for chickadees and one for titmice. All have strong legs and short, stout bills. The chickadees all have a dark cap and bib; the titmice all have a short crest.

Perhaps you are now feeling that this is more name and classification information than you really need. That the Tufted Titmouse and Black-capped Chickadee are closely related can be seen by watching their similar behavior, as for example, the manner in which both open up sunflower seeds. Both are responsive, curious, and often very tame. They may travel together in the same foraging groups along with nuthatches and woodpeckers.

The chickadee is easily recognized by its most familiar call, the name-saying chick-a-dee-dee-dee, but it also has a variety of other calls which it uses to communicate with other chickadees. However, sometimes the chickadees that are calling are not chickadees. Sometimes the call (to use Sibley’s description) is a series of angry, nasal, rising notes: sii, sii, zhree, zhree, zhree. Or they are whining scolds: seswee-jjeeer (Kaufman). Then we are hearing the Tufted Titmouse.

The Tufted Titmouse, like so many of our winter birds, is drab - gray above and white below, with rusty orange along its flank. What it lacks in showiness, it makes up for in attitude - or at least in the attitude it evokes within me. I am cheered and amused and entertained whenever the titmouse comes to the feeder.

Best of all, it seems to grab at the flimsiest excuse to sing. A brief peek of sun on a crisp  winter day, and I am greeted with the clear whistled peeer ... peeer ... peeer, or pee-ter ... pee-ter ... pee-ter of the Peter-bird - the Tufted Titmouse.

The seed in the Tufted Titmouse's beak helps to explain its northward range expansion - bird feeders.